I am a learning strategist and technologist with a passion for making a difference. My interests include all things eLearning, learning technologies, and instructional design. If you share my interests and want to discuss - AWESOME! I look forward to the collaboration.
Friday, January 16, 2009
Design
Design specifications include:
- Development of learning objectives that map to on the job requirements
- Section titles and topologies that indicate breakdown and sequence by module, lesson, and topic, which is also known as MLT
- Specification of instructional supports
- Targeting of critical learning objects for test, interactive, and certification development
- Specification of learning group differences and roles where applicable (multi-user design)
- Use of interactive exercises and practicums that map to job tasks
- Media types
- Timing estimates
Practical design structure at the module or lesson levels:
- Tell'em
> Learning objectives
> Explain what the learner will learn and why
- Show'em
> Demonstrate the task or concept
- Walk'em through it
> Guide and coach through the task
> Provide feedback as prompting
- Have'em try it
> Provide the learner with an opportunity to experience task with minimum feedback
- Have'em apply it
> Provide a real-world problem scenario where the learner can use the new skill
> Test the learner in a situation he or she will likely encounter on the job
- Tell'em again
> Reiterate the learning objective and explain what was accomplished
The structure above can be modified by using the parts that are appropriate. What is important is the progression from what is explained or demonstrated - to the transfer of learning.
Risks if not conducted or conducted improperly:
- Misdirected development efforts due to a lack-of or inaccurate architectural specifications
- (Think of trying to get from point A to point B in unfamiliar territory without a map)
- Extended development timelines and cost due to design error and misdirection
- A course that does not meet the required needs of the participants resulting in project failure and a dissatisfied stakeholder
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Analysis and Planning: Technical and Media Specifications Analysis
- Identify infrastructure capabilities for courseware delivery
- Identify requirements for optimal delivery media
- Identify stakeholder standards for text, graphics, media, and branding
- Graphics and media that do not meet the standards and satisfaction of the stakeholder
- Incorrect delivery formats
- Product failure due to incompatibility of delivery medium and/or components to the hardware and software requirements of the stakeholder and/or the stakeholder’s customers
- Missed deadlines and extended project plans that do not meet stakeholder expectations
- Is based on the needs of the organization/department
- Addresses the gap between the required task-KSAs and what’s actually done by the learner on the job
- Is delivered using the appropriate mediums and technologies that map to learner profiles
Monday, December 8, 2008
National Learning Week
L - Learning
E - Evaluation or eLearning
A - Assessment or Activities
R - Reinforcement or ROI
N - Networking
They are posting and distributing responses out to members with one letter of the acronym for each day of the week. Here is my submission:
L:
At some level, we are all in the business of Learning, but what do we mean when we refer to learning, behavior, or training? The following definitions can be useful from an operational standpoint... Let’s start with our subject - the learning-participant or learner. The assumption is that learners behave in a certain way until they learn to behave in another, through some sort of experience. Let’s define behavior as something that a participant does that can be observed and measured. If so, then we can agree that any measurable change in behavior is some sort of learning. That being said, the training experience needs to be the purposeful cause of that measurable change in behavior so that what is learned is consistent and applicable.
E:
Some Evaluation questions to ask your self after learning events or better yet - to prepare for during course development: Do they like it? Do they know more now than they did before training? Can they do more now than they could before training? Are work-performance outcomes better now than they were before training? Are departmental or business metrics better now than they were before training? How am I ruling out confounding variables (reasons “other than training” for your evaluation data)?…
A:
What to analyze when Assessing the need for training: Define the sponsoring organization’s/department’s mission, goals, vision, culture, obstacles to performance and budget for training. Identify and what learners need to do in “an ideal world” for their job-roles in terms of tasks, knowledge, skills, and abilities. Validate what learners are actually doing in “the real world” for their job-roles in terms of tasks, knowledge, skills, and abilities. Identify the capabilities and limitations of your learners in terms of education-level, experience, and available technologies. Use assessment results to design and develop content that focuses on the gap between the ideal and real world requirements while accounting for organizational needs and learner capabilities.
R:
When designing and developing content, apply Reinforcement principles to learning events as ABCs:
B = Behavior – is what the learner does; ideally, meeting the learning objective.
C = Consequences – these are are anything that happens after behavior that can either reinforce (increase the likelihood) or punish (decrease the likelihood) that what was learned will be applied on the job. Build and deliver activities that reinforce: Tell’em > Show’em > Let’em Try It (guided) > Let’em Apply It (unguided) > and Test’em. Also, use reminders, job aides, feedback, and supervisor support to reinforce behavior back on the job.
N:
Use social Networking and Web 2.0 tools to learn: Blog to broadcast subject matter expertise; micro-blog to keep your team abreast of newly learned knowledge and skills; write wikis to share and update reference-able knowledge-bases between team members; video short info-bytes or demonstrations from vid-cam at your desktop for your corporate YouTube. Don't have a budget? Get permission to use free tools like Blogger, WordPress, PBwiki, WetPaint, Twitter, Google Docs and Reader.
Happy National Learning Week!
Saturday, December 6, 2008
Analysis and Planning: Learner Analysis
- Identify logistics of the base learning pool
- Detail role characteristics for learner profiles
- Gauge current performance measures and characteristics for comparison against what is required in training
- Develop an approach to providing targeted recurrent training based on identified performance gaps as required by stakeholder
- Ensure training program complements activities relating to recruitment and performance appraisal as required by stakeholder
- Not understanding the learner - your customer
- A course that does not focus on the gap between tasks/KSAs assessed as required in “a perfect world” and task/KSAs the learner was doing before the learning event in “the real world”
- Delivery modalities that do not meet the differing needs of course participants
- Training that does not result in improved on the job performance criteria
- Dissatisfied course participants and a dissatisfied stakeholder
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
Analysis and Planning: Task-KSA Analysis
- Existing courseware provided by the stakeholder when possible
- Supporting documentation as provided by the stakeholder when possible
- Information as solicited through Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) provided by the stakeholder
- Identification of critical tasks, knowledge, skills, and abilities
- Identification of critical success factors for training outcomes
- Review of existing curriculum and suggest necessary modifications
- Specification of information sources/references
- Development of parameters for on-the-job training
- Development of parameters for training targeted to specific technologies/equipment
- Development of performance metrics and standards to govern the training process, as well as learner performance
- Coverage of material already mastered by course participant/learners
- Missing coverage of material required on the job for course participant/learners based on material not captured during the Task/KSA Analysis
- Loss of internal and predictive validity as there is no baseline for success comparison
- A course that does not focus on the gap between tasks/KSAs assessed as required in “a perfect world” and task/KSAs occurring in “the real world”
- Delivery modalities that do not meet the differing needs of course participants
- Training that does not result in improved on the job performance criteria
- Inhibited transfer of training due ignorance of group perceived function and/or climate issues not planned for during training design (e.g. The difference between how upper management perceives what is required for sales database training and what sales people out in the field perceive as required)
- Dissatisfied course participants and a dissatisfied stakeholder
Sunday, November 30, 2008
Analysis and Planning: Organizational Analysis
This sub-phase identifies organizational readiness for the learning solution. The organizational analysis validates and aligns the stakeholder’s mission and objectives with strategic delivery of a courseware solution, as mutually confirmed by stakeholder decision makers and the delivery team. The organizational analysis identifies critical information for the developed courseware solution, which should be mapped to criteria for behavior-based learning outcomes, performance outcomes, learner characteristics, and return on investment measures. Data should be mapped to the design phase as appropriate. An organizational analysis summary should be submitted.
Data collected at this stage includes:
- Critical success factors for synchronous and/or asynchronous training
- Confirmation of mission objectives
- Identification of training goals, expectations, and success measures
- Identification for points-of-contact
- Identification of systemic support factors
- Identification of constraining variables
- Confirmation that the problem to be addressed is based on a skill deficit vs. a performance or systemic deficit
- Paralleling project charter and planning
- The solution does not meet expectations of decision-makers
- Misalignment of the course expectations with organizational or departmental goals, values, mission, and vision
- Support factors, external constraints, and climate related factors that do not facilitate transfer of training and thus result on project failure
- Losses of internal and predictive validity as benchmarks are not tailored to organizational needs for predicting success. (Internal validity looks at if training made any difference at all. Predictive validity is how training should predict success on the job based on criterion measures.)
- Miscommunication between the various constituencies of the stakeholder and the development team
- Development of a training solution for an outcome-oriented problem that requires a systemic or motivational solution
- Missed deadlines - extended project plans, and unforeseen obstacles to product success that do not meet stakeholder expectations due to a lack of proactive planning
- A dissatisfied stakeholder due to misdirected planning
Saturday, November 29, 2008
Analysis and Planning
The Analysis and Planning phase should include some level of the following sub-phases:
- Organizational Analysis
- Task-KSA Analysis
- Learner Analysis
- Technical and Media Specifications Analysis
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
ISD and the ADDIE Model
A - Analysis
D - Design
D - Development
I - Implementation
E - Evaluation
Execution of each phase is dependent on how a development team and stakeholders agree on the project's approach typically specified within a statement of work or project charter. As a system of checks and balances, each phase and milestone requires stakeholder approval to assure that what is delivered at project completion is what the stakeholder has approved from the beginning.
When no or little preexisting courseware exists, the most critical phase of a project is Analysis. Each phase follows sequentially with exception to Evaluation, which if conducted properly, occurs continuously throughout the process. Details regarding each phase will follow in subsequent blog entries. However, for a high level explanation of how this should work, see the graphic below.
It is fair to say that many in the business of course development skip phases within this model and some even ignore the model completely. This is a mistake, but please do not misinterpret that to mean that this process cannot be performed efficiently or within short time-frames. Those of us who work in internal training departments or on the customer business side need only to perform an analysis on a periodic basis for each department or customer-base we serve.Also, variations in this model exist along with compressed methodologies and adaptations based on stakeholder needs. How this can be accomplished will be addressed in subsequent entries. Stay tuned for details on each phase of the ADDIE model.
Friday, November 14, 2008
Learning/Web 2.0 Collaboration for Mentoring and to Wrap Learning Events
http://www.trainingmag.com/msg/content_display/publications/e3i34ff3e76aa1f48788ed288b9cf20826a
Friday, November 7, 2008
How to Use Discussions within Learning Contexts
A threaded discussion is an electronic discussion - in which the software aids the user by visually grouping messages. Messages are usually grouped visually in a hierarchy by topic. A set of messages grouped in this way is called a topic thread or simply "thread". A discussion forum - is said to have "threaded topics" if it groups messages on the same topic together for easy reading in this manner. Moreover, threaded discussions typically allow users to reply to particular posting within a topic's thread. As a result, there can be a hierarchy of discussions within the thread topic. Various types of software may allow this hierarchy to be displayed in what's called Threaded Mode. (The alternative being Linear Mode, which typically shows all of the posts in date order, regardless of who may have specifically replied to whom.)
View more of the Wikipedia description here.
Focused Discussions:
These are a no brainer and are therefore the most popular. What is key is ensuring the topics of the discussion are directly related to the learning objectives. Focused discussions can prep your learners for upcoming events, serve as a breakouts between sessions, or keep the conversations going and relevant to the job long after any formal learning activity. If the discussion tool supports threaded mode, participants will be able to branch into sub-topics where appropriate.
Note-taking:
Great synchronous activity - while in-class, take notes, but not in your notepad or to a doc on your laptop, but within a note-taking discussion group. Later, participants of the discussion can share and compare notes. The instructor can correct, provide, and get feedback if appropriate. Everyone benefits.
Homework:
An instructor gives an assignment - the learner is asked to post it within a homework discussion room. Great for group assignments, but if privacy is required due to concerns regarding sensitivity or copying - have them submit homework in password protected zip packages or set-up 1:1 discussion rooms between the instructor and each learner.
Brainstorming Sessions:
Typically a breakout or between session activity, a brainstorming session may be assigned as an activity where learners are asked to apply content they just learned to resolve an open-ended scenario or existing problem at their workplaces. If the tool has the ability to freeze idea threads as they are posted - even better as this functionality supports the brainstorming philosphy of "no idea is a bad idea."
To-do Lists:
To-do lists are a great follow-up to a learning event. The learner just took a course, now have them publicly post what they will do with their new knowledge, skills, and abilities. While others read, they may be inspired to do the same, the similar, or completely innovative based on the sparks that are lit.
Goal Planning:
Goal planning discussions are an excellent post-work activity where learners must turn learning objectives from a course into SMART goals they will achieve on the job. (SMART = specific, measurable, attainable but difficult, relevant, and time-framed.) Goals set by others can motivate participants to set similar goals or build on their ideas. Coaches and or peers can review and provide feedback.
Action Planning:
In the last activity participants identified their goals - an action planning discussion is where they can collaborate and plan on how to achieve those goals with their managers and supervisors. Great way to transform what was learned into practice.
Scorecards:
Great post-work activity where teams are required to post business metrics relevant to how the content that was learned is improving efficiencies, productivity, sales metrics, or any other measurable outcome related to the learning experience and job context. Scorecards, scoreboards, and dashboards work on the premise that what gets monitored changes and when combined with learning activity, provide a very powerful feedback and reinforcers. You might have them brainstorm on what to measure and how prior to this... Bottom line - these really work and managers who send their employees to training love them.
Lounge:
Classroom based training typically offers a lounge, lobby, cafe, or even water cooler area where participants can take a break. As learning experiences become more electronic, we may need to provide virtual learners with a virtual lounge area so they can take that break and come back fresh into the learning experience. If you are concerned about the type of discussion that may take place, provide guidelines and moderate as required.
Wrapping:
Wrapping using a discussion thread is the truly packaged and blended learning experience. The entire learning activity can be coordinated through discussion if appropriate - from scheduling, to preparation, and evaluation. Keep the discussions relevant by embedding links, attaching appropriate materials, providing feedback, and facilitating discussion on relevant topics that speak to the learners needs. Instructors can assign pre-work, breakout sessions, home work, and post-work around self-paced or live learning events.
Of course, there are other ways to use discussions as part of the blended learning experience. Membership in an ongoing discussion can be leveraged as a reinforcer to learning. They can be used as an incentive to participation and or completion where access to subject matter experts and peers with similar problems or experience is perceived as a benefit. In sum, use discussion threads to expand the digital tribe through social contact and by tying formal learning to the informal.